Jurisdictional immunities of states in the context of compensation paid by russia for the damage caused in Ukraine as a result of its armed aggression

Maryna MEDVEDIEVA

MEDVEDIEVA M. (2023), Jurisdictional immunities of states in the context of compensation paid by russia for the damage caused in Ukraine as a result of its armed aggression, Scientific Bulletin of Dnipropetrovsk State University of Internal Affairs 2023, №1, 44-52

 

ABSTRACT. The article analyzes the means of compensation by Russia for the damage caused in Ukraine as a result of its armed aggression, their problematic and positive features, taking into account the norms of international law regarding the jurisdictional immunities of states and their property. The author considers such means in the context of jurisdictional immunities of russia, as administrative procedures created in Ukraine (with the help of Ukrainian state funds); legal proceedings in Ukrainian and foreign courts; decisions of international courts and arbitral tribunals; international compensation commission. The author offers various options for overcoming russia’s jurisdictional immunities.

The author makes an analysis of the problem referring to national and foreign national legislation, international conventions, decisions of Ukrainian and foreign courts as well as the judgments of international courts such as the International Court of Justice and the European Court of Human Rights.

The article concludes that it is of paramount importance to introduce into the legislation of Ukraine restrictions on the jurisdictional immunities of foreign countries if they cause damage to individuals, legal entities, the state, in particular as a result of aggression, and at the same time, through diplomatic channels, to seek the introduction of similar norms into the law of other countries. The author upholds the idea to set up a special compensation commission on the basis of an international treaty, where a ‘tort exception’ must be ensured.

The article assumes that changes to national legislation and new judicial practice of various states gradually become proof of the existence of a norm of customary international law, which allows limiting the jurisdictional immunities of states and their property in the event of harm caused during armed conflicts.

Key words: jurisdictional immunities, immunity of state property, aggression, international law, damage, armed conflict.

References:

  1. Pro kompensatsiiu za poshkodzhennia ta znyshchennia okremykh katehorii obiektiv nerukhomoho maina vnaslidok boiovykh dii, terorystychnykh aktiv, dyversii, sprychynenykh viiskovoiu ahresiieiu Rosiiskoi Federatsii [On compensation for damage and destruction of certain categories of real estate objects as a result of hostilities, acts of terrorism, sabotage caused by the military aggression of the Russian Federation] : рroekt Zakonu Ukrainy. URL : https://itd.rada.gov.ua/billInfo/Bills/pubFile/1248275. [in Ukr.].
  2. Pro vidshkoduvannia shkody zavdanoi poterpilomu vnaslidok zbroinoi ahresii Rosiiskoi Federatsii [On compensation for damage caused to the victim as a result of the armed aggression of the Russian Federation] : рroekt Zakonu Ukrainy. URL: https://itd.rada.gov.ua/billInfo/Bills/pubFile/1306069. [in Ukr.].
  3. Vodiannikov, O. Ahresyvni imunitety i imunnyi ahresor: mizh zakonodavtsem i suddeiu [Aggressive immunities and the immune aggressor: between the legislator and the judge]. LB.ua: Doroslyi pohliad na svit. 26 serpnia 2022 r. URL : https://lb.ua/blog/oleksandr_vodennikov/527485_agresivni_imuniteti_i_imunniy.html. [in Ukr.].
  4. Marshuk, Yu. Sposoby vidshkoduvannia shkody zapodiianoi vnaslidok zbroinoi ahresii rosii [Ways of compensation for damage caused as a result of russia’s armed aggression]. 15 veresnia 2022 r. URL: https://dominanta-law.com/sposoby-vidshkoduvannya-shkody-zapodiyanoyi-vnaslidok-zbroynoyiahresiyi-rosiyi. [in Ukr.].
  5. Cherniak, Yu. (2022) Pytannia yurysdyktsiinoho imunitetu u praktytsi Verkhovnoho Sudu (na prykladi tsyvilnykh pozoviv do Rosiiskoi Federatsii pro vidshkoduvannia shkody) [The issue of jurisdictional immunity in the practice of the Supreme Court (on the example of civil lawsuits against the Russian Federation for compensation of damage)]. Ukrainskyi chasopys mizhnarodnoho prava. №3. рр. 60-66. [in Ukr.].
  6. Karnaukh, B. Territorial Tort Exception? The Ukrainian Supreme Court Held that the Russian Federation Could Not Plead Immunity with regard to Tort Claims Brought by the Victims of the RussiaUkraine War. Access to Justice in Eastern Europe. 2022. Vol. 3, № 15. P. 165-177. URL: https://ajeejournal.com/territorial-tort-exception-the-ukrainian-supreme-court-held-that-the-russian-federation-couldnot-plead-immunity-with-regard-to-tort-claims-brought-by-the-victims-of-the-russia-ukraine-war.
  7. Marchenko, O. Ahresor z pidirvanym imunitetom: yak sudy spriamovuiut hroshi Rosii na kompensatsiiu vtrat vid viiny [An aggressor with compromised immunity: how courts direct money to Russia to compensate for war losses]. Ukrainska pravda. 8 chervnia 2022 r. URL: https://www.eurointegration.com.ua/articles/2022/06/8/7140806/. [in Ukr.].
  8. Vodiannikov, O. Compensation Mechanism for Ukraine: An Option for Multilateral Action. OpinioJuris. 13 May 2022. URL: https://opiniojuris.org/2022/05/13/compensation-mechanism-forukraine-an-option-for-multilateral-action/.
  9. Pro robochu hrupu z rozrobky ta vprovadzhennia mizhnarodno-pravovykh mekhanizmiv vidshkoduvannia shkody, zavdanoi Ukraini vnaslidok zbroinoi ahresii Rosiiskoi Federatsii [About the working group on the development and implementation of international legal mechanisms for compensation for damage caused to Ukraine as a result of the armed aggression of the Russian Federation] : Ukaz Prezydenta Ukrainy №346/2022 vid 18 travnia 2022 r. URL: https://www.president.gov.ua/documents/3462022-42577. [in Ukr.].
  10. Giorgetti, Ch., Kliuchkovsky, Pearsall, P. Ctvorennia mizhnarodnoi spetsialnoi komisii dlia Ukrainy [Creation of an international special commission for Ukraine]. Just Security. 20 May 2022. URL: https://www.justsecurity.org/81862/launching-an-international-claims-commission-for-ukraine-ua/. [in Ukr.].
  11. Pro obmezhennia imunitetu inozemnykh derzhav ta yikh posadovykh i sluzhbovykh osib vid prediavlennia pozoviv ta stiahnennia shkody zavdanoi na terytorii Ukrainy smertiu abo ushkodzhenniam zdorovia, a takozh shkody, zavdanoi mainu vnaslidok zbroinoi ahresii, tymchasovoi okupatsii terytorii Ukrainy, inshykh dii chy bezdiialnosti [On limiting the immunity of foreign states and their officials and employees from filing lawsuits and recovering damage caused on the territory of Ukraine by death or injury to health, as well as damage caused to property as a result of armed aggression, temporary occupation of the territory of Ukraine, other actions or inaction] : рroekt Zakonu Ukrainy URL: https://itd.rada.gov.ua/billInfo/Bills/pubFile/1407689. [in Ukr.].
  12. Bornkamm, P. (2012) State Immunity Against Claims Arising from War Crimes: The Judgment of the International Court of Justice in Jurisdictional Immunities of the State. German Law Journal. Vol. 13, № 6. R. 773-782.
  13. Hryshko, V. Vidshkoduvannia shkody za porushennia prav liudyny ta derzhavnyi imunitet: chy zmozhut ukrainski sudy sudyty rosiiu? [Compensation for human rights violations and state immunity: will Ukrainian courts be able to judge Russia?]. 31 travnia 2022 r. URL: https://dejure.foundation/tpost/vmnoy46hu1-vdshkoduvannya-shkodi-za-porushennya-pra. [in Ukr.].
  14. European Convention on State Immunity, 1972. URL: https://rm.coe.int/16800730b1.
  15. United Nations Convention on Jurisdictional Immunities of States and Their Property, 2004. URL: https://treaties.un.org/doc/source/recenttexts/english_3_13.pdf.
  16. Draft articles on Jurisdictional Immunities of States and Their Property, with commentaries, 1991. URL: https://legal.un.org/ilc/texts/instruments/english/commentaries/4_1_1991.pdf.
  17. Jurisdictional Immunities of the State (Germany v. Italy: Greece intervening). Judgment of the International Court of Justice of 3 February 2012. URL: https://www.icj-cij.org/public/files/caserelated/143/143-20120203-JUD-01-00-EN.pdf.
  18. Gragl, P. (2019) Jurisdictional Immunities of the State in International Law. The Oxford Handbook of Jurisdiction in International Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press. P. 228-249.
  19. General Assembly adopts resolution on Russian reparations for Ukraine. UN News. 14 November 2022. URL: https://news.un.org/en/story/2022/11/1130587.
  20. Badanova, I. Jurisdictional Immunities v Grave Crimes: Reflections on New Developments from Ukraine. EJIL:Talk! 8 September 2022. URL: https://www.ejiltalk.org/jurisdictional-immunities-v-Науковий вісник Дніпропетровського державного університету внутрішніх справ. 2023. № 1 52 ISSN 2078-3566 grave-crimes-reflections-on-new-developments-from-ukraine/.
  21. Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949, and Relating to the Protection of Victims of International Armed Conflicts, 1977. URL: https://www.icrc.org/en/doc/assets/files/other/icrc_002_0321.pdf.
  22. Blank, L. War Reparations for Ukraine: Key Issues. Just Security. 2 May 2022. URL: https://www.justsecurity.org/81341/war-reparations-for-ukraine-key-issues/
Views: 121